Harbaugh Agonistes*

In 1991 the Stanford football team enjoyed one of its finest seasons in quite some time, finishing the regular season at 8-3 before losing in the Aloha Bowl on Christmas Day.  As exciting as it was, some of the expected joy was diminished due to constant speculation about the future of the head coach.  No one, it seemed, could imagine that a young, successful coach would want to remain at Stanford to build a consistent program since the NFL would offer more money and greater prestige.  But our head coach repeatedly put our fears to rest, declaring several times that he wasn't interested in any other job -- until he left a few weeks after the season to become the head coach of the Minnesota Vikings.  I was young at the time, only a year removed from campus, so I took this very personally and vowed to refer to him from that moment on as the Two-Faced Denny Green.  

Strictly from a fan's point of view, the sudden departure of a successful head coach can be difficult.  Even though there were lots of signs (most of them dollar signs) pointing towards this eventual outcome, the seventy-two hour emotional roller coaster ride that preceded Harbaugh's signing with the 49ers was unbelievably gut-wrenching.

Last week's Orange Bowl victory stands as the pinnacle of Stanford Football in my twenty-five years of fandom, but that moment was tainted even as the trophies were being hoisted.  The first questions directed to Harbaugh and Andrew Luck were about where they'd be in 2011, and Harbaugh's deflections to those inquiries were predictable.  He had nothing to say.  

But there were clues dropped in answers to other questions that troubled me.  He kept referring to the win as a "championship," even though it clearly wasn't.  He talked about his players as "champions," even though they had finished second in the Pac-10.  It sounded to me as if he was trying to convince people -- and maybe even convince himself -- that he had fulfilled one of his stated goals upon taking the job four years ago, his promise to win a championship.  During that press conference I knew he was leaving.

But then something strange happened.  As the offers were pouring in and rumor-mongers were already installing him in places like Ann Arbor, Denver, San Francisco, and Miami, there was a glimmer of hope.  Different voices were telling us that Harbaugh was having a hard time walking away from Stanford, and we were hearing that the contract offer already on the table was being sweetened.  When the Miami Dolphins dropped out of the picture, it looked like maybe -- maybe --  he might stay.  Only forty-eight hours earlier it had looked like Stanford football would be entering the 2011 season without either Luck or Harbaugh, but after Luck announced his decision to stay on Thursday afternoon, there were moments Thursday evening when people believed they'd both be returning.  Instead of worrying about a need to rebuild the program, I was thinking about a national championship run.

When news broke on Friday of Harbaugh's decision to leave for the 49ers, I was disappointed but not surprised.  Afterall, this was what I had been worrying about for months.  Here's what I wrote about the 49er job back on October 27: 

This, I think, is the biggest threat.  Even though things have been rough recently, the 49ers are still seen as one of the NFL's marquee teams, and I bet Harbaugh would love to be the guy that returns the franchise to glory.  What's worse is that the 49er practice facility and offices are just 11.6 miles from Palo Alto, meaning that the Harbaugh family wouldn't even have to move...

I was angry when the Two-Faced Denny Green abandoned ship, but somehow it's different with Jim Harbaugh.  Maybe it's only because I'm 41 and not 22, or maybe it's because I've had several months to get used to the idea, but I feel no animosity towards Harbaugh.  He changed the culture of Stanford Football, dramatically improved the level of talent in the program, and convinced the nation -- heck, he even convinced me -- that Stanford University could field a top-flight football team.

If you hire a coach ambitious enough to believe that he can take over a 1-11 disaster and win a championship, this is the risk that you take.  Stanford's next coach won't be in that same position.  He won't have to imagine what might be possible for Stanford football, because he will already see it, and that just might keep him here longer than four years.  Maybe, just maybe, the Stanford head coaching position has become a destination rather than a stepping stone.  We have Jim Harbaugh to thank for that.

* Apologies to John Milton and Tom Verducci.

[Photo Credit: Ezra Shaw/Getty Images]

Comments

[Ralph]

I will be pissed only if he takes one or more of the assistants along. That always seems to me like poaching.

[Lici]

Yes, I've gone through much of the emotions (and thinking process) that you have. Maybe it's that when you're in your 40s (as I am, also) one's vision of career is a more mature one. It becomes about a progression toward a goal, and who can begrudge someone for reaching for that goal?

The trip to the Orange Bowl was unforgettable, as was the team's season. But I had a strange feeling seeing Harbaugh and the players on the podium. Although I was happy, it felt bittersweet. I wasn't even as happy with that win as I was watching Big Game. I felt certain that he was gone, although in my case, I just had a sense of it based on reading his body language and the way he spoke.

In retrospect, with Michigan out of the picture, everything pointed to the '9ers: The desire to relive the success of Bill Walsh; his background in the Bay Area and his family's comfort there; his brother's success in the NFL; the feeding frenzy making this an optimal time to jump ship.

Unlike with Green (or Tyrone Willingham, who seemed to blow up his bridges with Stanford), I think Harbaugh can keep his ties with Stanford. No one I've talked to harbors anything less than thankfulness for what he's done.

[Hu]

JH gave us exactly what we deserved; despite a season's worth of rumors, he kept his team focused and committed. He never allowed it to become a distraction, he never publicly addressed the rumors, and he certainly never made any Two Faced Denny Green statements, even when it might have helped. We knew he was going soon, he knew he was going, but he kept his end of the bargain by keeping his head down and doing a good job for Stanford, and never speaking out of both sides of his mouth. I'd have liked him to stay, but this was as classy a way as you could leave a program.

[Harley]

Though I agree with the two-faced-ness of what Denny Green did, I still can't fault a college head coach for jumping to the NFL when the opportunity arises. The move makes sense for money and for prestige. The only thing that's worse about the NFL is you're likely to get fired within a couple of years if you have mediocre seasons.

Given some time, I don't suspect I'll fault Harbaugh too much for making this move.

The one that really stunk was Tyrone. I was that guy's biggest fan for the work ethic and the motivation level he instilled in the team. That he jumped laterally (at best) to a Notre Dame team with losing record and arguably worse prospects really sucked. No doubt Notre Dame offered him more money than the Card could. But still... Tyrone's stated ambition was to be an NFL head coach. He was well on his way and coaching at a college that has a proven track record of making that happen. Instead he went to a place with fans who have notoriously unrealistic expectations, did a mediocre job and got fired after only three seasons. Then he had some less than mediocre seasons at UW, and now his career is seemingly over. Where is Tyrone these days anyhow?