I believe that the Mighty Card will beat USC this weekend. After navigating what amounts to the preseason portion of the schedule, Coach David Shaw has given his new quarterback confidence and an increasing amount of responsibility within the offense, the offensive line has coalesced, and the defense has regained its leader.
Stanford has beaten USC three years in a row and four of the past five, and that trend should continue. Even though the Trojans have a clear advantage at the offensive skill positions and overall team speed, there's a sense that Stanford simply matches up well against USC. Coach Shaw's NFL experience prepared him well to design a game plan and call plays against USC's Tampa 2 defense, a scheme that was all the rage during Shaw's various stints with Philadelphia, Oakland, and Baltimore, and the defense has always performed well enough against Matt Barkley and company to secure the win. (Oregon, on the other hand, a team similar to USC in many respects, is a decidedly bad matchup for the Cardinal. Coach Shaw still hasn't figured out how to compete with them, but we've got a couple months before we have to worry about that.)
The problem with this analysis, of course, is that it's far from unbiased. If you were to travel across the country and ask a thousand randomly selected college football fans with no connection to Stanford University about this Saturday's game between the Cardinal and the Trojans, I'm guessing that about 995 of them would pick USC to win.
But I am connected to Stanford University, and the people I talk to about football either lived in my freshman dorm or populate a message board focused on Stanford sports. There's a possibility that I lack the proper perspective to offer an accurate preview of this game. In an effort to provide a more balanced opinion, I sought out someone with a strong bias in the other direction. Enter Will Robinson of the USC blog, Conquest Chronicles, who was kind enough to answer some of my questions. It's a great read, even if he did dodge a couple of my more insightful questions. Enjoy...